This question may feel unusual at first, but interviewers ask it for a reason. When they say, “On a scale of one to ten, rate me as an interviewer”, they want to understand how you give feedback and how comfortable you are responding to a question that involves evaluating someone in authority.
Your response helps the interviewer assess your communication skills, emotional intelligence, and professionalism. For roles involving leadership or teamwork, this question can also reveal how respectfully you handle praise and criticism.
Important things to keep in mind
- Keep your response positive and respectful.
- Focus on what the interviewer did well rather than pointing out flaws.
- Explain your rating clearly instead of just giving a number.
- Show that you were attentive and engaged throughout the interview.
- Maintain a calm and confident tone while answering.
You can also mention how the interviewer made the discussion comfortable, especially if you felt nervous initially. This shows honesty and appreciation.
What interviewers look for in your answer
- Your ability to give constructive and thoughtful feedback
- Your respect for people in positions of authority
- Your communication and reasoning skills
- Your maturity and professional attitude
Mistakes you should avoid
- Do not give a rating without explaining your reason.
- Avoid extremely low or extremely high ratings.
- Do not sound sarcastic, casual, or overly critical.
- Avoid insecure responses that undervalue your opinion.
Interviewers appreciate honesty, but they also expect courtesy and respect. A balanced and well-explained answer always leaves a better impression.
Sample answers
-
Sample Answer 1
“I would rate you a 9 out of 10. You made the interview very comfortable, and your questions were clear and relevant, which helped me explain my skills and experiences effectively. You also gave me the opportunity to ask questions, which I really appreciated. I believe there is always room for improvement, which is why I would not say a perfect 10.” -
Sample Answer 2 (Fresher-friendly)
“As a fresher, I may not have enough experience to judge interviews in detail, but from my perspective, I would rate this interview a 9. You made the discussion easy to follow and encouraged me to share my thoughts openly. I found the experience very professional and positive.”
The key is to be polite, thoughtful, and confident. A well-balanced answer shows that you respect the interviewer while also expressing your views clearly.
All the best.
Practise it out loud
Answering in your head is not the same as saying it. Take 30 seconds to plan, then speak for up to 90 seconds as if the interviewer is in front of you.
Ready when you are
From the community
How students answered
Well, I don't think anyone can be a good judge of anything in such a short time span. I believe it would be naive of me to think that I can rate you out of ten at your own job by only spending 30 minutes with you. However,…
Read full answerI think you are the one who rates the people on basis of their talent. So I'm not the right one to rate you because I can't judge people within a short period of time. Infact, this is a special ability of HR and I'm not…
Read full answerSir, I won't be able to rate you as I feel I don't desrve to rate a person whose work position as an abbreviation i.e. HR already opens up to a phrase called 'Highly Rated'.
Read full answer