LearnFrenzy
Sign in Take a free test

Reading Comprehension: Long Passages · Exercise 7 of 8

Reading Comprehension: Long Passages Argument, Inference & Author’s View

  • 35 questions
  • Page 1 of 4
  • Answers explained
0Attempted
0Correct
0Wrong
Directions

35 hard questions on argumentative passages: specialists and generalists, algorithms, the happiness paradox, car-centred cities and the replication crisis.

Question 1 Hard

Read the passage and answer the question that follows.

Modern economies prize specialisation. The surgeon who performs one kind of operation thousands of times, the engineer who knows everything about a single type of chip – such experts are rewarded with high pay and respect, and for good reason. In fields where the rules are stable and feedback is quick, deep practice in a narrow area produces remarkable skill.

But not every field is like that. Many of the problems that matter most – in public policy, business strategy or scientific research – are messy and unpredictable, and the rules change as one works on them. Here the specialist’s strength can become a weakness. Trained to see problems through one lens, he may miss solutions that are obvious to someone from another discipline. Some of the most important innovations have come from people who carried an idea from one field into another, where no specialist had thought to apply it.

Generalists have their own weaknesses, of course. Breadth without depth can lead to superficial judgements, and a person who knows a little about everything may be unable to do anything well. The argument, then, is not that specialists should give way to generalists, but that institutions which reward only narrow expertise may lose something valuable. Universities that discourage students from exploring outside their main subject, and firms that keep employees in a single role for decades, may be producing people who are very good at answering the questions they have been given and poor at noticing when the questions themselves are wrong.

Perhaps the ideal is the person with one area of deep knowledge and a wide range of interests around it – sometimes described as “T-shaped”. Such people can contribute expertise while also making connections across boundaries. Encouraging them requires a willingness to tolerate apparent detours: the engineer who studies history, the doctor who reads philosophy. These detours, far from being a waste of time, may be where the most original thinking begins.

What is the author’s main argument?

A Institutions should value breadth as well as depth, as in “T-shaped” people.
B Specialists should be replaced by generalists in universities, firms and public life.
C Generalists are always more creative than specialists.
D Specialisation has no value in modern economies, so universities should stop training experts altogether.
Discuss in Forum
Question 2 Hard

Read the passage and answer the question that follows.

Modern economies prize specialisation. The surgeon who performs one kind of operation thousands of times, the engineer who knows everything about a single type of chip – such experts are rewarded with high pay and respect, and for good reason. In fields where the rules are stable and feedback is quick, deep practice in a narrow area produces remarkable skill.

But not every field is like that. Many of the problems that matter most – in public policy, business strategy or scientific research – are messy and unpredictable, and the rules change as one works on them. Here the specialist’s strength can become a weakness. Trained to see problems through one lens, he may miss solutions that are obvious to someone from another discipline. Some of the most important innovations have come from people who carried an idea from one field into another, where no specialist had thought to apply it.

Generalists have their own weaknesses, of course. Breadth without depth can lead to superficial judgements, and a person who knows a little about everything may be unable to do anything well. The argument, then, is not that specialists should give way to generalists, but that institutions which reward only narrow expertise may lose something valuable. Universities that discourage students from exploring outside their main subject, and firms that keep employees in a single role for decades, may be producing people who are very good at answering the questions they have been given and poor at noticing when the questions themselves are wrong.

Perhaps the ideal is the person with one area of deep knowledge and a wide range of interests around it – sometimes described as “T-shaped”. Such people can contribute expertise while also making connections across boundaries. Encouraging them requires a willingness to tolerate apparent detours: the engineer who studies history, the doctor who reads philosophy. These detours, far from being a waste of time, may be where the most original thinking begins.

According to the passage, deep specialisation works best in fields where

A problems are messy and keep changing as one works
B many disciplines must work together
C the rules are stable and feedback is quick
D the rules change all the time
Discuss in Forum
Question 3 Hard

Read the passage and answer the question that follows.

Modern economies prize specialisation. The surgeon who performs one kind of operation thousands of times, the engineer who knows everything about a single type of chip – such experts are rewarded with high pay and respect, and for good reason. In fields where the rules are stable and feedback is quick, deep practice in a narrow area produces remarkable skill.

But not every field is like that. Many of the problems that matter most – in public policy, business strategy or scientific research – are messy and unpredictable, and the rules change as one works on them. Here the specialist’s strength can become a weakness. Trained to see problems through one lens, he may miss solutions that are obvious to someone from another discipline. Some of the most important innovations have come from people who carried an idea from one field into another, where no specialist had thought to apply it.

Generalists have their own weaknesses, of course. Breadth without depth can lead to superficial judgements, and a person who knows a little about everything may be unable to do anything well. The argument, then, is not that specialists should give way to generalists, but that institutions which reward only narrow expertise may lose something valuable. Universities that discourage students from exploring outside their main subject, and firms that keep employees in a single role for decades, may be producing people who are very good at answering the questions they have been given and poor at noticing when the questions themselves are wrong.

Perhaps the ideal is the person with one area of deep knowledge and a wide range of interests around it – sometimes described as “T-shaped”. Such people can contribute expertise while also making connections across boundaries. Encouraging them requires a willingness to tolerate apparent detours: the engineer who studies history, the doctor who reads philosophy. These detours, far from being a waste of time, may be where the most original thinking begins.

Why can the specialist’s strength become a weakness in messy problems?

A Seeing through one lens, he may miss solutions from other fields.
B Messy problems require no expertise at all, so his training is wasted.
C Specialists are paid too much to work hard.
D Specialists refuse to work in teams with people from other disciplines.
Discuss in Forum
Question 4 Hard

Read the passage and answer the question that follows.

Modern economies prize specialisation. The surgeon who performs one kind of operation thousands of times, the engineer who knows everything about a single type of chip – such experts are rewarded with high pay and respect, and for good reason. In fields where the rules are stable and feedback is quick, deep practice in a narrow area produces remarkable skill.

But not every field is like that. Many of the problems that matter most – in public policy, business strategy or scientific research – are messy and unpredictable, and the rules change as one works on them. Here the specialist’s strength can become a weakness. Trained to see problems through one lens, he may miss solutions that are obvious to someone from another discipline. Some of the most important innovations have come from people who carried an idea from one field into another, where no specialist had thought to apply it.

Generalists have their own weaknesses, of course. Breadth without depth can lead to superficial judgements, and a person who knows a little about everything may be unable to do anything well. The argument, then, is not that specialists should give way to generalists, but that institutions which reward only narrow expertise may lose something valuable. Universities that discourage students from exploring outside their main subject, and firms that keep employees in a single role for decades, may be producing people who are very good at answering the questions they have been given and poor at noticing when the questions themselves are wrong.

Perhaps the ideal is the person with one area of deep knowledge and a wide range of interests around it – sometimes described as “T-shaped”. Such people can contribute expertise while also making connections across boundaries. Encouraging them requires a willingness to tolerate apparent detours: the engineer who studies history, the doctor who reads philosophy. These detours, far from being a waste of time, may be where the most original thinking begins.

Which concession does the author make in the third paragraph?

A Specialists produce all of the most important innovations.
B Universities already encourage exploration.
C Firms rarely keep employees in one role.
D Breadth without depth can lead to superficial judgements.
Discuss in Forum
Question 5 Hard

Read the passage and answer the question that follows.

Modern economies prize specialisation. The surgeon who performs one kind of operation thousands of times, the engineer who knows everything about a single type of chip – such experts are rewarded with high pay and respect, and for good reason. In fields where the rules are stable and feedback is quick, deep practice in a narrow area produces remarkable skill.

But not every field is like that. Many of the problems that matter most – in public policy, business strategy or scientific research – are messy and unpredictable, and the rules change as one works on them. Here the specialist’s strength can become a weakness. Trained to see problems through one lens, he may miss solutions that are obvious to someone from another discipline. Some of the most important innovations have come from people who carried an idea from one field into another, where no specialist had thought to apply it.

Generalists have their own weaknesses, of course. Breadth without depth can lead to superficial judgements, and a person who knows a little about everything may be unable to do anything well. The argument, then, is not that specialists should give way to generalists, but that institutions which reward only narrow expertise may lose something valuable. Universities that discourage students from exploring outside their main subject, and firms that keep employees in a single role for decades, may be producing people who are very good at answering the questions they have been given and poor at noticing when the questions themselves are wrong.

Perhaps the ideal is the person with one area of deep knowledge and a wide range of interests around it – sometimes described as “T-shaped”. Such people can contribute expertise while also making connections across boundaries. Encouraging them requires a willingness to tolerate apparent detours: the engineer who studies history, the doctor who reads philosophy. These detours, far from being a waste of time, may be where the most original thinking begins.

A “T-shaped” person, as described in the passage, is one who

A knows a little about everything but nothing in real depth
B has deep knowledge in one area and wide interests around it
C works in two unrelated jobs at once
D specialises in technology and engineering
Discuss in Forum
Question 6 Hard

Read the passage and answer the question that follows.

Modern economies prize specialisation. The surgeon who performs one kind of operation thousands of times, the engineer who knows everything about a single type of chip – such experts are rewarded with high pay and respect, and for good reason. In fields where the rules are stable and feedback is quick, deep practice in a narrow area produces remarkable skill.

But not every field is like that. Many of the problems that matter most – in public policy, business strategy or scientific research – are messy and unpredictable, and the rules change as one works on them. Here the specialist’s strength can become a weakness. Trained to see problems through one lens, he may miss solutions that are obvious to someone from another discipline. Some of the most important innovations have come from people who carried an idea from one field into another, where no specialist had thought to apply it.

Generalists have their own weaknesses, of course. Breadth without depth can lead to superficial judgements, and a person who knows a little about everything may be unable to do anything well. The argument, then, is not that specialists should give way to generalists, but that institutions which reward only narrow expertise may lose something valuable. Universities that discourage students from exploring outside their main subject, and firms that keep employees in a single role for decades, may be producing people who are very good at answering the questions they have been given and poor at noticing when the questions themselves are wrong.

Perhaps the ideal is the person with one area of deep knowledge and a wide range of interests around it – sometimes described as “T-shaped”. Such people can contribute expertise while also making connections across boundaries. Encouraging them requires a willingness to tolerate apparent detours: the engineer who studies history, the doctor who reads philosophy. These detours, far from being a waste of time, may be where the most original thinking begins.

The phrase “poor at noticing when the questions themselves are wrong” implies that narrow training

A is the best way of finding the right questions to ask
B makes people bad at answering the questions they are given
C produces people who ask too many questions
D may discourage people from questioning assumptions
Discuss in Forum
Question 7 Hard

Read the passage and answer the question that follows.

Modern economies prize specialisation. The surgeon who performs one kind of operation thousands of times, the engineer who knows everything about a single type of chip – such experts are rewarded with high pay and respect, and for good reason. In fields where the rules are stable and feedback is quick, deep practice in a narrow area produces remarkable skill.

But not every field is like that. Many of the problems that matter most – in public policy, business strategy or scientific research – are messy and unpredictable, and the rules change as one works on them. Here the specialist’s strength can become a weakness. Trained to see problems through one lens, he may miss solutions that are obvious to someone from another discipline. Some of the most important innovations have come from people who carried an idea from one field into another, where no specialist had thought to apply it.

Generalists have their own weaknesses, of course. Breadth without depth can lead to superficial judgements, and a person who knows a little about everything may be unable to do anything well. The argument, then, is not that specialists should give way to generalists, but that institutions which reward only narrow expertise may lose something valuable. Universities that discourage students from exploring outside their main subject, and firms that keep employees in a single role for decades, may be producing people who are very good at answering the questions they have been given and poor at noticing when the questions themselves are wrong.

Perhaps the ideal is the person with one area of deep knowledge and a wide range of interests around it – sometimes described as “T-shaped”. Such people can contribute expertise while also making connections across boundaries. Encouraging them requires a willingness to tolerate apparent detours: the engineer who studies history, the doctor who reads philosophy. These detours, far from being a waste of time, may be where the most original thinking begins.

The tone of the passage is best described as

A angry and rather dismissive
B balanced but persuasive
C purely descriptive
D humorous and ironic
Discuss in Forum
Question 8 Hard

Read the passage and answer the question that follows.

Algorithms increasingly make, or help to make, decisions that once belonged to people: who is shortlisted for a job, who receives a loan, which posts appear in a news feed, even which neighbourhoods police patrol most heavily. Their supporters point out that human decision-makers are far from perfect. People are inconsistent, tired, swayed by mood and prone to prejudice, often without realising it. A well-designed system, they argue, can apply the same criteria to everyone.

The difficulty is that algorithms learn from data, and data record the past – including its injustices. A hiring system trained on the records of a company that has mostly promoted men may learn to favour applicants who resemble those men, even if it is never told anyone’s sex. Because the system’s reasoning is buried in complex statistics, such bias can be harder to detect than the prejudice of an individual manager, and it can be applied to thousands of decisions at once.

There is also the question of accountability. When a human official refuses an application, the applicant can ask why and appeal. When a system produces a score, even its operators may be unable to explain exactly how it was reached. Decisions that cannot be explained are difficult to challenge, and responsibility can disappear somewhere between the company that built the system, the organisation that uses it and the data it learned from.

None of this means that algorithms should be banned from important decisions; in many cases they can improve on human judgement. It means that their use should come with conditions: testing for bias before and after they are put to work, explanations that affected people can understand, a human able to review and overturn decisions, and clear rules about who is responsible when things go wrong. Fairness, in other words, must be designed in, not assumed.

Which statement best expresses the author’s position?

A Algorithms can help but should be used only with safeguards.
B Algorithms should be banned from all important decisions about people.
C Algorithms are always fairer than human beings.
D Human decision-makers never make mistakes, so algorithms should not be used at all.
Discuss in Forum
Question 9 Hard

Read the passage and answer the question that follows.

Algorithms increasingly make, or help to make, decisions that once belonged to people: who is shortlisted for a job, who receives a loan, which posts appear in a news feed, even which neighbourhoods police patrol most heavily. Their supporters point out that human decision-makers are far from perfect. People are inconsistent, tired, swayed by mood and prone to prejudice, often without realising it. A well-designed system, they argue, can apply the same criteria to everyone.

The difficulty is that algorithms learn from data, and data record the past – including its injustices. A hiring system trained on the records of a company that has mostly promoted men may learn to favour applicants who resemble those men, even if it is never told anyone’s sex. Because the system’s reasoning is buried in complex statistics, such bias can be harder to detect than the prejudice of an individual manager, and it can be applied to thousands of decisions at once.

There is also the question of accountability. When a human official refuses an application, the applicant can ask why and appeal. When a system produces a score, even its operators may be unable to explain exactly how it was reached. Decisions that cannot be explained are difficult to challenge, and responsibility can disappear somewhere between the company that built the system, the organisation that uses it and the data it learned from.

None of this means that algorithms should be banned from important decisions; in many cases they can improve on human judgement. It means that their use should come with conditions: testing for bias before and after they are put to work, explanations that affected people can understand, a human able to review and overturn decisions, and clear rules about who is responsible when things go wrong. Fairness, in other words, must be designed in, not assumed.

What argument do supporters of algorithms make?

A Algorithms can explain every decision they make, unlike human managers.
B Algorithms are cheaper than human workers.
C Humans are inconsistent and biased; algorithms apply the same rules to all.
D Algorithms never need data to make decisions.
Discuss in Forum
Question 10 Hard

Read the passage and answer the question that follows.

Algorithms increasingly make, or help to make, decisions that once belonged to people: who is shortlisted for a job, who receives a loan, which posts appear in a news feed, even which neighbourhoods police patrol most heavily. Their supporters point out that human decision-makers are far from perfect. People are inconsistent, tired, swayed by mood and prone to prejudice, often without realising it. A well-designed system, they argue, can apply the same criteria to everyone.

The difficulty is that algorithms learn from data, and data record the past – including its injustices. A hiring system trained on the records of a company that has mostly promoted men may learn to favour applicants who resemble those men, even if it is never told anyone’s sex. Because the system’s reasoning is buried in complex statistics, such bias can be harder to detect than the prejudice of an individual manager, and it can be applied to thousands of decisions at once.

There is also the question of accountability. When a human official refuses an application, the applicant can ask why and appeal. When a system produces a score, even its operators may be unable to explain exactly how it was reached. Decisions that cannot be explained are difficult to challenge, and responsibility can disappear somewhere between the company that built the system, the organisation that uses it and the data it learned from.

None of this means that algorithms should be banned from important decisions; in many cases they can improve on human judgement. It means that their use should come with conditions: testing for bias before and after they are put to work, explanations that affected people can understand, a human able to review and overturn decisions, and clear rules about who is responsible when things go wrong. Fairness, in other words, must be designed in, not assumed.

How might a hiring algorithm come to favour men, according to the passage?

A Its designers deliberately chose to exclude women from the shortlist.
B It learns from past records of a company that mostly promoted men.
C It is programmed to ask every applicant’s sex.
D Women apply for jobs less often than men.
Discuss in Forum

Ready to test your Verbal Ability?

Timed online tests with instant scores and explanations.

Search LearnFrenzy

Esc

Quick links