Read the passage and answer the question that follows.
By most estimates, more than a third of India’s population now lives in towns and cities, and the share is rising every year. People move for jobs, education and the hope of a better life, and cities generate most of the country’s economic output. Yet urban growth has often run ahead of planning. Housing, water supply, sewerage and transport have struggled to keep up with the number of new arrivals.
One result is the spread of informal settlements – neighbourhoods built by residents themselves on land they do not formally own. Such settlements are often described only in terms of what they lack: proper sanitation, secure tenure, paved roads. That picture is true but incomplete. Many are also busy centres of work, where small workshops, shops and services provide livelihoods, and where residents have built strong networks of mutual help.
For decades, the official response was frequently eviction and demolition, sometimes followed by resettlement on the far edges of the city. Families moved to distant sites often lost their jobs and social networks, and some drifted back. More recent approaches favour upgrading settlements where they stand – providing water, toilets, drains and legal recognition – while involving residents in decisions.
Upgrading is not cheap, and it raises difficult questions about land that is needed for other purposes. But experience suggests that it is usually less disruptive and more effective than starting over. Cities that treat their poorer residents as part of the urban economy, rather than as a problem to be removed, are more likely to grow in a way that works for everyone.
What is the author’s main argument?
The passage contrasts eviction with upgrading and concludes upgrading is “less disruptive and more effective”.
Trap: saying settlements “lack nothing” ignores the sanitation and tenure problems the passage admits.
Answer: Upgrading informal settlements usually works better than evicting residents.