Concept Framework
Passage-Based Analysis and Main Idea · Study material
Main idea, titles and summaries
Topic, main idea and detail
| Level | What it is | Example (not used in the exercises) |
|---|---|---|
| Topic | What the paragraph is about, in a word or two | Bamboo houses |
| Main idea | What the writer says about the topic – one full sentence | Bamboo houses suit flood-prone areas because they are light, cheap and quick to rebuild. |
| Detail | Facts, examples and reasons that support the main idea | A bamboo house can be rebuilt in a week. |
The main idea is often – but not always – stated in a topic sentence, usually the first or last sentence. When it is not stated, combine the details and ask what single point they all support.
Too narrow, too broad, just right
| Option type | Example for the bamboo paragraph |
|---|---|
| Too narrow (a detail) | A bamboo house can be rebuilt in a week. |
| Too broad | Houses must be designed for their climate. |
| Distorted | Bamboo is the strongest building material. |
| Just right | Bamboo houses suit flood-prone areas because they are light, cheap and quick to rebuild. |
Titles and summaries
A title names the main idea in a few words and matches the tone – a lively title for a light piece, a plain one for a report. A summary restates the main idea and the key supporting points, in fewer words and without adding anything. Reject a summary that adds an opinion the writer did not express, changes “may” to “will”, or leaves out the writer’s turn (“however …”).
Purpose, tone and paragraph structure
Purpose: why was the paragraph written?
| Purpose verb | Signs |
|---|---|
| to inform / explain / describe | Facts, process, no strong opinion |
| to argue / persuade / urge | A claim, reasons, often a call to action |
| to criticise / condemn | Faults pointed out, disapproving words |
| to praise / pay tribute | Admiring detail about a person or group |
| to warn | Risks, consequences, “never”, “before it is too late” |
| to entertain / amuse | Exaggeration, comic detail, light ending |
| to recall / reflect | Memories, personal thoughts, quiet ending |
Tone: how does the writer sound?
| Tone | Marks |
|---|---|
| objective | Neutral facts, no adjectives of praise or blame |
| critical / indignant | Disapproval; indignant adds anger at injustice |
| admiring / appreciative | Warm praise |
| nostalgic | Fond longing for the past |
| ironic / sarcastic | Saying the opposite of what is meant; sarcasm is sharper and mocking |
| sceptical | Doubting a claim |
| cautionary / urgent | Warning; urgent adds “now” |
| optimistic / sympathetic | Hopeful; feeling for others’ suffering |
Structure: how is the paragraph built?
| Pattern | Signal words |
|---|---|
| Claim and support | for example, because, this shows |
| Problem and solution | the problem, one answer, to solve this |
| Cause and effect | so, as a result, therefore |
| Comparison and contrast | but, whereas, unlike, similarly |
| Common belief, then correction | many think … in fact, however |
| Chronological | first, then, later, finally, dates |
Sentence roles: introduces the topic, states the main claim, gives an example, offers a reason, presents an objection, answers an objection, draws the conclusion.